Every sales leader faces this dilemma at some point: what do you do when your highest-performing rep is damaging the team culture?
I recently spoke with a leader facing this exact challenge. His rep had been with the company for over two years and was making more than $300,000 annually—by far the top performer. But his behavior was tearing down the team.
The Problem Beneath the Performance
According to his CTS SalesProfile, this rep was:
-
Highly analytical and skeptical
-
Low in compassion and had zero social drive
-
Resistant to recognition, sales meetings, and leadership
-
Uncoachable and dismissive of company processes
Despite closing 35% of his leads, his customer satisfaction scores were poor. He had openly ridiculed leadership, trashed previous employers, and disrupted team training sessions. His presence in the room was draining, not inspiring.
The sales leader asked, “What do I do with a guy like this?”
The Advice: Culture Over Performance
I told him: This isn’t a hard decision—it’s just a hard one to make.
This isn’t about revenue. It’s about culture. And culture multiplies everything.
A toxic presence—even a productive one—can undermine team morale, confuse new hires, and erode trust. If you let one person skip meetings, rewrite the playbook, or mock leadership, you’re not managing a team—you’re being held hostage by one rep.
One thing every leader must remember: Your culture is not for sale. Not even to a $300,000 closer.
How to Respond
Here’s what I advised:
-
Confront the behavior directly and respectfully.
-
Reinforce expectations—meetings, methods, and team standards are non-negotiable.
-
Refuse to tolerate side processes that create confusion or division.
-
Plan for replacement if alignment can’t be achieved.
It’s unlikely this rep will change. His personality scores suggest he’s resistant to coaching, low in trust, and driven to work alone. You cannot build a healthy, high-performing culture around someone who refuses to grow with the team.
Leadership Means Protecting Culture
Leading isn’t just about celebrating top performers—it’s about protecting the values that help your entire team succeed.
When someone threatens that with negativity, isolation, or arrogance, you have a choice:
Confront it—or let your team pay the price.